Skip to main content
Faulty product

Your purchase broke after a few months? The seller may still be responsible.

The washing machine, phone or car part stopped working long before it should have. Attorly helps you work out whether it counts as a defect and which deadlines apply, and writes the complaint to the seller.

Start my complaint

Not legal advice: This page explains, in plain language, how a legal document typically works. It is general information — not legal advice about your specific situation. If the stakes are meaningful, or a deadline is close, speak with a licensed lawyer before relying on anything you read here.

The seller is responsible

Across the EU and EEA, goods you buy as a consumer from a business must match the contract and be fit for the purposes goods of that type are normally used for, with the durability, functionality and safety that are normal for them and that you can reasonably expect. EU law makes the seller liable for any lack of conformity that existed at delivery and becomes apparent within at least two years.

Your claim is against the business you bought from. A manufacturer's or seller's guarantee comes on top of your legal rights and does not replace them, and those rights cannot be signed away in advance. The EU rules are a minimum: your national law may give you more time or more protection.

Attorly reads the receipt, the order confirmation and the seller's replies, finds the rules that apply and shows the sources, keeps track of the deadlines and drafts the complaint and any follow-up letters. If a lot is at stake, a lawyer should look at it.

How it works

Get clarity on any legal document in three steps

Step 1

Upload your document

Drag in a PDF, Word file, or image scan. Any format, any language.

Step 2

Attorly analyzes it

The AI model you choose reviews your document under its governing law — flagging risks, extracting deadlines, and identifying obligations and key terms.

Step 3

Know exactly what to do

More than a summary — Attorly gives you a clear action plan: what matters, what to do about it, and in what order. Handle it yourself or bring a lawyer in fully prepared.

What Attorly looks at in a faulty-product case

The questions that decide whether you succeed — and what you can claim.

Is it a lack of conformity?

The goods must match the contract and be fit for their normal purpose, with the durability, functionality and safety normal for goods of that type. What the seller or manufacturer said in advertising or on the label can also count.

Who has to prove what

A fault that becomes apparent within one year of delivery is presumed to have existed at delivery, unless the seller proves otherwise or the presumption does not fit the goods or the fault. Some countries extend this to two years.

The deadlines

The seller is liable for faults that become apparent within at least two years of delivery; many countries give longer. For purchases from 31 July 2026, if the fault is fixed by a repair you chose, that period is extended once by 12 months, and national law may extend it further (countries with a different system must give at least three years after a repair). Where national law requires you to notify the seller, the deadline cannot be shorter than two months from when you discovered the fault. For second-hand goods, some countries allow a shorter agreed period, but not under one year.

Who pays

Repair and replacement must be free of charge, the seller takes back replaced goods at its own expense, and you do not pay for normal use of the item before it was replaced. If you end the contract, you return the goods at the seller's expense and the seller refunds you once it receives them or your proof of sending.

What the seller's refusal rests on

Attorly checks whether the refusal relies on something the law cares about — or on a referral to the manufacturer, an expired guarantee or an unsupported claim of misuse. It then drafts a reasoned reply that points to the rules.

Withholding payment

If part of the price is still unpaid, you can withhold payment until the seller has met its obligations. How this works in practice is set by national law.

Compensation for other losses

EU law covers repair, replacement, price reduction and refunds. Whether you can also claim for losses the fault caused you — damage to other property, costs you incurred — is a matter for national law, which usually allows it on conditions.

When something you bought has failed

The order matters — and in many countries a clock starts when you discover the fault.

  1. 1

    Describe it in Attorly

    Tell Attorly what you bought, when it was delivered and what happened, or upload the receipt and the seller's reply. Attorly assesses whether it may be a lack of conformity, shows the deadlines that apply where you live, and adds them with reminders.

  2. 2

    Tell the seller in time

    Notify the seller as soon as you can after discovering the fault, and do it in writing so you can prove when you complained. Some countries require notice within a set period; EU law allows such a deadline, but never one shorter than two months from when you discovered the fault.

  3. 3

    Keep the evidence

    Take photos or video of the fault, keep the receipt, the order confirmation and every message — and the item itself. Do not throw it away or have it repaired elsewhere before the seller has had a chance to examine it, or it may become hard to show what was wrong.

  4. 4

    Choose repair or replacement

    You can choose between repair and replacement, unless your choice is impossible or would cost the seller disproportionately more than the other. It must be done free of charge, within a reasonable time and without significant inconvenience to you. For purchases from 31 July 2026, the seller must tell you about this choice, and that choosing repair extends its liability period, before it fixes the fault.

  5. 5

    Ask for a price reduction or your money back

    If the seller does not repair or replace, refuses, or the fault comes back after an attempt, you can claim a proportionate price reduction or end the contract and get a refund. The seller can only stop you ending it by proving the fault is minor. Compensation for other losses depends on national law.

  6. 6

    Use consumer dispute resolution

    If the seller still refuses, every EU country has approved out-of-court dispute-resolution bodies for consumer complaints, usually quicker and cheaper than court. For a purchase from a business in another EU or EEA country, the European Consumer Centre in your country can help.

Common questions about faulty products

Complain before the deadline runs out

Describe the fault and Attorly sets up the case, the deadlines and the letter to the seller.

Write my complaint